AMERICAN POLITICS & PUBLIC POLICY WORKSHOP
Abstract: When scholars address presidential agenda setting, they focus on how presidents go about getting what they want. We know far less about the prior step: how presidents decide what they want (agenda construction). Moreover, prior work that has dealt with this topic has focused on the external constraints imposed on presidential choice by Congress and public opinion. I contend, by contrast, that presidents have considerable agency in determining their domestic policy priorities. They rely on it to establish who they are and where they want to take the nation, putting forward their own “political projects.” I situate this agency in the selection of agenda items and the manner and sequence in which presidents pursue them. Failing to account for this “power of initiative and origination” leaves us with an underspecified understanding of presidential decision-making that obscures the consequentiality of leadership in driving important policy outcomes. I develop this argument by exploring three presidential administrations that pose a hard test for my agency thesis: Richard Nixon, George H. W. Bush, and George W. Bush. These case studies draw from archival records obtained at the associated presidential libraries and interviews with senior administration personnel.
Jack Greenberg is a PhD candidate in political science and a resident graduate affiliate of the Institution for Social and Policy Studies. His work focuses on presidential leadership in the context of America’s system of separated powers. His first book, Congressional Expectations of Presidential Self-Restraint, is under contract with Cambridge University Press, and his research has previously appeared in Presidential Studies Quarterly and Evaluating the Obama Presidency (De Gruyter 2024). He directs the Dahl Research Scholars program and serves as a graduate adviser to the Program on Ethics, Politics, and Economics.
Open to the Yale community only. Please visit this link to subscribe and receive regular announcements: https://csap.yale.edu/american-politics-public-policy-workshop.